I’ve come to the conclusion that most people who have never experienced depression have no idea how to react when I tell them I have a mental illness. They either look away and change the subject, or say some infuriating things. I often bite my tongue to hold back my honest replies. Here is a compilation of my ‘favourites’, and the things I would love to say back but daren’t:
1. What do you have to be depressed about? – Do you really want me to explain how depression works!? There is often no reason, which makes it especially difficult to come to terms with. But if you must have something to blame then I’m struggling at university/in debt/going through a divorce/my mum has cancer and everything has got on top of me … queue more awkward questions.
2. But you don’t look depressed – What does a depressed person look like? Did you expect to come to my house and find me still in bed at 3pm, crying in to my pillow? No, because I’ve fine tuned my acting skills. I put a brave face on and pretend everything is ok.
3. Have you taken your antidepressants today? – Yes! Medication isn’t a magic wand. I’ll still have occasional down days. But actually the reason I’m annoyed with you is because you washed your red football socks with my white underwear and now it’s pink … your idiocy has nothing to do with my depression.
4. Oh my sister/cousin/great auntie in transylvania had depression. He/she swears by lavender oil baths/listening to beethoven/drinking her own urine. Have you tried that? – Do you really think 1 in 4 people would be diagnosed as having clinical depression every year if it was as simple as bathing in flowers or sipping on a glass of your own pee!?
5. Man up/pull yourself together/snap out of it – Ah so that’s all I need to do!? For 6 months I’ve been struggling with life and all I needed to do was man up? Great advice. Maybe I’ll man up and drink my urine.
6. Think of all your reasons to be happy, you don’t know how lucky you are! – I do! I think about it all the time. That’s why I feel so guilty for having depression. However, depression often has no one thing to blame, it is an illness. It’s like saying that thinking happy thoughts can cure the flu or genital warts.
7. Go to the gym/join a tennis club/try bungee jumping – I avoid seeing my friends and other social situations, why would running around, getting sweaty, with a room full of strangers help!? And bungee jumping? I considered doing that last week … but without the bungee cord.
8. I really don’t know what to say or do to help. Did you see Eastenders last night? – Don’t change the subject, ask me how you can help if you want to. I’ve plucked up so much courage to tell you how I’m feeling … tell me you’ll always be there for me despite not understanding why I am depressed. Tell me you’ll listen and never judge me. And tissues, bring tissues. Unless you like tears and snot on your new jumper.
Do you have any that you’d like to add to my list? Rant away
Or what are the most helpful things people have said to you?
Here are a few ‘helpful’ additions from Twitter:
‘You only feel that way because you’re depressed’ @diski
‘You should try living in Sudan’ @lajineta

that’s probably it. i forgot my lavender today. hm.
Rookie mistake!
Excellent post, thanks very much. (Came across it via Zite by the way, so people all over the world are seeing it whether you know it or not.)
Just started a blog a few days ago and cross linked to it. Not sure if there’s a protocol for doing this but if I have broken it, please do let me know!
http://depressedacademics.blogspot.co.uk/2013/01/what-not-to-say-to-someone-with.html
love this post, thanks. I had a breakdown a couple of years ago and lost a lot of friends because they just found it too uncomfortable to be around someone that never cheered up.
incidentally, I firmly believe the thing that helped me more than medication and group therapy and this and that and the other is taking fish oil capsules every day. But that’s just me. Perhaps I should have tried the lavender oil!
Fish oil? That’s one I’ve not heard before
I lost friends too, but because I pushed them away when they wanted to help me. That’s a big regret of mine.
Yes!! And Holland & Barrett have a penny sale at the moment! Something to do with the brain being largely made up of fat or some hokum. Worked for me.
I never know what to say when people offer to help. It’s a bit like, er yeah if you could just wash all this blah out of my brain that would be fabulous thanks.
Yes I’ve faced all these. It’s hardest when it’s your close friends and family that are delivering these messages. I feel that people are mostly just afraid of not being able to fix you, not knowing that the help you need is very simple. You just need to be there, don’t leave, don’t judge and offer hugs and reassurance. Hope you’re doing ok at the moment. x
Thanks for your comment! You are totally right, people are worried about being able to help but a hug goes a long way
I’m doing very well at the moment thank you, I hope you are too. Just off to have a nosy at your blog now… x
Stopping by from MBPW.
Thanks for sharing this. Despite having had depression in the past, I also struggle to know what to say to people now. My step-dad is struggling at the moment, and I think I find it hard to talk to him about it because then I have to accept it’s real…and that’s scary. I hope you have people around you who can support you x
Thank you for commenting
Sorry to hear your step-dad is having a hard time. I do have people who understand and support me now, they were always there really I just needed to let them ‘in’. A few of my friends have depression/bi-polar and I just let them know I’m there for them should they want to talk about things. I also ask them how they are or how they’ve been coping. It used to upset me when I saw a friend who knew I had depression, and she never once asked how I was. I felt like she didn’t care but really I think she just felt very awkward approaching the subject of depression. Sorry for my novel length reply x
Such a true post! It’s probo why I rarely mention it to anyone, other than my husband, when I am feeling depressed. The thing is though, even though I am someone who does suffer with depression (luckily these days very occasionally), I’m still not sure what exactly to say to someone if they tell me they are depressed. I guess simply listening is the best thing, but it is so hard not to try and say something ‘helpful’, because usually the person who confides in you is someone you care about and naturally would want to help. It’s a tough one.